Whoever told you that only the knives and cookware had lifetime warranties was completely wrong! According to my 2002 Fall/Winter catalog the Stainless Steel Whisk, Twixit! Clip Combo Pack, Easy Clean Kitchen Brush, Cheese Knife, Self Sharpening Knives(now honing & 5 yr), Bread Knife, and the Generation II Lids all also had Lifetime Guarantees.
These changes to policy after the fact are driving me nuts!
Pampered Chef have never offered a Lifetime warranty on everything. When I started the Batter Bowl had a 10 year warranty, but we didn't start adding the warranty in the catalog until 2002. The furthest back I could find a PIG was 2007 and luckily it had some 2005 cookware info!
I think HO needs to train their reps on what was guaranteed and when it changed. Because according to the Product Informaion Guide in 2005 the Professional Cookware said absolutely NOTHING about nonstick aresole sprays voiding the cookware warranty. Here is are parts of a section that I found today in an old Product Information Guide file:
4-Piece Set with Bonus Nylon Tool Set COOKWARE --
Professional Cookware PROFESSIONAL
2760 4-Piece Set with Bonus Nylon Tool Set Lifetime guarantee...
...
USE AND CARE
Using Your Professional Cookware
Before use, hand wash using hot, soapy water and a nonabrasive sponge or cloth.
...
Medium to medium-high heat settings are recommended for most recipes. High heat should
be reserved for stir-frying, boiling, or reducing liquids.
The need for nonstick sprays is reduced when cooking with our Professional Cookware. For maximum durability of the Dupont™ Autograph® coating, use of nylon, bamboo or wood utensils is recommended to prevent marring of the interior surface. Avoid using knives or other sharp metal objects in hard-anodized cookware.
...it goes on, but I need to stop.
It says the need for such sprays is reduced. Not, using such sprays will void the warranty. I believe HO is right to refuse cookware that was abused - as long as they honor the warranty that came in the box at the time of purchase.